top of page

How to Handle Difficult Clients as a New Notary

Feb 14

3 min read

Notaries encounter a diverse range of clients, and while most interactions are straightforward, some can be unexpectedly challenging. Difficult clients may be argumentative, impatient, unprepared, or even hostile. Others may question your authority, resist legal requirements, or attempt to pressure you into notarizing improper documents.


 How to Handle Difficult Clients as a New Notary, The Notary Business Blueprint, The Notary Blueprint

Common Types of Challenging Clients

  • The Rushed Client – Impatient and demanding, often pushing you to skip necessary steps

  • The Skeptical Client – Doubts the notarization process and questions your every move

  • The Unprepared Client – Arrives without proper identification or with incomplete documents

  • The Disruptive Client – Engages in aggressive or inappropriate behavior, making it difficult to proceed

  • The Persuasive Client – Tries to convince you to bend the rules or notarize something improperly



Why Clients Become Difficult

Understanding a client's frustration can help you manage the situation effectively. Stress, lack of knowledge about notarization, urgency, or past negative experiences can all contribute to difficult behavior. Recognizing these triggers allows you to address concerns proactively and maintain control of the interaction.



The Impact on Your Notary Business

Handling difficult clients poorly can lead to negative reviews, legal risks, and unnecessary stress. However, mastering the art of diplomacy and professionalism can turn a challenging encounter into an opportunity to showcase your expertise.



Setting Clear Expectations from the Start

A well-structured approach to client interactions minimizes misunderstandings. Before meeting a client:

  • Explain the notarization process and legal requirements

  • Clarify document expectations (e.g., signers must have valid identification)

  • Outline your fees upfront to avoid disputes



Communicating Firmly but Respectfully

A difficult client may challenge your authority, but remaining professional is essential. Use a confident but calm tone when addressing concerns. Avoid getting defensive; instead, repeat the rules firmly and explain that notaries must follow legal guidelines, not personal preferences.



Knowing When to Decline a Notarization

Some clients will not accept your explanations or may insist on improper notarization.


You have the legal right—and responsibility—to refuse service if:

  • The client lacks proper identification

  • The document is incomplete or contains blank spaces

  • The client appears coerced or mentally incapable of signing

  • The request violates notary laws


Clearly state why you cannot proceed, document the refusal, and remain polite but unwavering.



Managing Conflict with Diplomacy

Difficult clients may try to provoke a reaction. Maintain composure and avoid matching their energy. Take deep breaths, pause before responding, and focus on neutral, professional language.



De-escalation Techniques for High-Tension Situations

When faced with an irate client, employ these strategies:

  • Acknowledge their frustration without agreeing to unreasonable demands

  • Use active listening to show you understand their concern

  • Offer solutions within legal guidelines, such as referring them to another notary



Addressing Misinformation and Unrealistic Demands

Some clients believe notarization grants legal power beyond its scope. If a client insists on incorrect procedures, calmly explain:

  • “A notarization does not validate the contents of the document—only the signer’s identity.”

  • “State/Provincial law requires me to witness the signing in person; I cannot notarize a pre-signed document.”


Sticking to factual, concise explanations prevents unnecessary debates.



Protecting Yourself Legally and Financially

Maintaining a detailed notary journal protects you from legal disputes. Log every notarization, including refusals, with:

  • Client’s name and ID details.

  • Type of document notarized.

  • Date, time, and location.

  • Notes on unusual interactions.


This record serves as legal protection if a client later challenges your actions.



Avoiding Liability Traps with Difficult Clients

Some clients may try to involve you in unethical or fraudulent activities. Protect yourself by:

  • Never advising on legal matters—direct clients to an attorney

  • Refusing to notarize suspicious documents

  • Double-checking IDs to avoid identity fraud



Turning a Negative Experience into a Positive One

Each challenging encounter provides valuable experience. Reflect on:

  • What triggered the client’s frustration?

  • How effectively did you maintain control of the situation?

  • What could you do differently next time?



Strengthening Your Customer Service Skills

Handling difficult clients with patience and professionalism builds trust. Over time, you will refine your ability to navigate tense situations effortlessly.



Building a Reputation for Professionalism

Word-of-mouth can make or break a notary’s business. Clients may not always like your decisions, but they will respect consistency and professionalism. By standing firm on legal principles while maintaining a courteous demeanour, you establish yourself as a credible, trustworthy notary.


Difficult clients are inevitable, but they don’t have to derail your confidence or reputation. By setting clear boundaries, staying calm under pressure, and protecting yourself legally, you can handle challenging interactions with poise and professionalism—ensuring long-term success in your notary career.




Related Posts

Comments

Share Your ThoughtsBe the first to write a comment.
bottom of page